- Home
- Resources
- The queue in a CNAP: how long people are willing to wait and why the ticket does not show everything
The queue in a CNAP: how long people are willing to wait and why the ticket does not show everything
Author: DuoVision team
For: heads of CNAPs, service centres and executive bodies of communities
Summary
- A continuous survey of visitors to Texas police service centres showed that satisfaction hardly suffers up to 30 minutes of waiting, and after that the rating falls; the study does not publish the sample size, so this is a guide.
- In California in August 2018 a DMV visitor without an appointment waited 114 minutes on average, and in six months the wait was cut to 57 minutes with temporary staff, a longer working day and kiosks.
- In Ukraine 93.2% of CNAP visitors are satisfied with the service, but we found no public data on waiting time.
- A queue management system sees only the tickets issued and called; it does not count companions, people at the information desk or those who left without a number, and a camera in the hall can count them too.
For: heads of CNAPs, service centres and executive bodies of communities
114 minutes in the queue for a driving licence
In the summer of 2018 California began issuing driving licences of the new federal REAL ID type in large numbers. The number of people who had to come in person grew considerably, and the offices of the Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) could not cope.
In April 2019 the Senate Budget Committee of the state gave these figures for visitors without an appointment in its hearing background paper:
| California, DMV | August 2018 | January 2019 |
|---|---|---|
| Average wait | 114 min | 57 min |
| 20 offices with the longest queue | 177 min | 95 min |
| People who waited over 2.5 hours | almost 150,000 | 2,035 |
According to the DMV, waits were cut with temporary staff, a longer working day for offices and self-service terminals. In August 2018 the agency was given an additional USD 16.6 million and 230 positions. The average still hid the worst: even in January 2019 in the 20 busiest offices people waited an hour and a half on average.
In the same paper the committee warned that queues would most likely grow again: at that point the DMV had issued about 3.4 million REAL ID licences and was due to issue another 16-20 million over several years. Temporary staff and money remove one peak, and to avoid being caught off guard by the next one, you need to see every day how the hall fills up.
How long people are willing to wait
The Institute for Organizational Excellence at the University of Texas at Austin runs a continuous survey of visitors to the service centres of the Texas Department of Public Safety, which issues driving licences. The researchers' conclusion: short waiting time is the main factor in how people rate the service, and up to 30 minutes of waiting satisfaction hardly suffers. After that the rating drops noticeably. The study page gives no sample size, so 30 minutes should be treated as a guide only.
For the head of a CNAP the conclusion is simple. The average wait over a day says little. It is more useful to know how many people waited longer than your threshold, and in which hours.
What is known about CNAPs in Ukraine
In January 2022 the Ministry of Digital Transformation published the results of a nationwide assessment of the quality of administrative services. More than 38 thousand responses were collected through calls, SMS, Viber and QR surveys in 2,300 centres. 93.2% of visitors are satisfied with the service, and 78.9% are ready to recommend a CNAP to friends. Mystery shoppers made 1,500 visits to 344 CNAPs for the 9 most popular services, and by their assessment the centres meet the quality requirements by 81.3%.
Waiting time is not given in these results. We found no other nationwide data on how long people stand in a queue at a CNAP.
The regulation does contain a requirement, though. The Model Regulation of a CNAP, approved by Cabinet Resolution No. 588, in clause 23 obliges the centre to take measures so that a queue does not form and, when it does, to manage it. Clause 9 ties the area of the waiting sector to the number of visitors per day. But at peak hours there can be more people in the hall than the daily average, and that is when seats may run out.
Why the ticket does not show everything
A queue management system knows when a ticket was issued and when a number was called. It does not see a person standing at the information desk to find out whether they need a ticket. It does not see a companion waiting with the applicant. It does not count those who looked at the hall and left without taking a number.
Cameras are usually already installed in CNAP halls. On the same image, video analytics can be set up to count:
- how many people are in the waiting sector each hour and when there are more than seats;
- how long on average a person waits before reaching a window, without identifying the person;
- how many windows actually worked in each hour against the schedule;
- when more people than your norm gather by the terminal and a consultant is needed exactly there.
When the number of people in the hall exceeds the number of seats for longer than the agreed time, the administrator receives a card with a frame and decides whether to open another window. We set up the rules for the specific centre and first run them in shadow mode, when the cards are reviewed only by the centre's responsible person and no alerts go to the administrator yet. The system does not recognise faces. We agree the purpose of processing and the camera placement with you before launch, because a CNAP hall is a public place.
Where to start
- Define your threshold: how many minutes of waiting are already too many for your centre. The Texas guide of 30 minutes works as a starting point.
- Count the seats in the waiting sector and check whether your existing cameras see the whole hall, the entrance and the terminal.
- Decide who receives the overcrowding alert and what that person does: opens a window, comes out into the hall, moves people to another type of service.
- Over a week, compare the number of tickets issued by hour with the number of seats in the hall, and mark the hours when there are more tickets than seats.
- Ask the supplier whether you can start with shadow mode on existing cameras and whether the system stores only numbers, without identifying the person.
We connect to the cameras that already hang in the hall and work in shadow mode for the first weeks.
Where to apply this
- Public and municipal sector
- Site security and vehicles
- Video analytics for warehouses: aisles, forklifts, the dock and people in the machinery zone
- License plate recognition for warehouses and plants: what it gives, which cameras work, what drives accuracy
- Video surveillance cameras with artificial intelligence: which ones work and whether you need new ones
Sources
- California Senate Budget and Fiscal Review Committee. Department of Motor Vehicles: Wait Times and Operational Improvements, 22.04.2019
- Institute for Organizational Excellence, The University of Texas at Austin. Texas Department of Public Safety Customer Satisfaction Surveys
- Government portal. 93% of Ukrainians are satisfied with CNAP service: results of the nationwide assessment of administrative service quality, 20.01.2022
- Cabinet of Ministers Resolution of 01.08.2013 No. 588. Model Regulation of the administrative service centre