- Home
- Resources
- Knives at the deboning line: safe storage and whether a camera can watch an unattended knife
Knives at the deboning line: safe storage and whether a camera can watch an unattended knife
Author: DuoVision team
For: heads of HACCP, process engineers, deboning supervisors and occupational safety specialists at meat processing plants
Summary
- A knife left unattended on a table is a risk to people (cuts) and to the product (contact with raw meat and surfaces). The Western Australian regulator calls the knife the cause of the most lost-time injuries in abattoirs.
- Regulation (EC) 853/2004 requires cutting plants to have facilities for disinfecting tools with hot water at not less than 82 °C, or an equivalent system. Ukrainian Order No. 590 does not mention knives directly.
- Sterilizers were closed units that cameras could not see. The rule we ran checked something else: a knife lies at a workstation and nobody is near it for longer than a set time.
- The system took holes in tables for knives, and in one case it missed an object. The rule is not among those we have proven: it was only tuned, and on a new site it starts in shadow mode.
For: heads of HACCP, process engineers, deboning supervisors and occupational safety specialists at meat processing plants
Why is a knife left on the table at a deboning line dangerous?
There are two reasons. The first concerns people. Hand cuts make up a noticeable share of injuries in the industry; we went through the US statistics in the article on glove control and do not repeat the figures. The regulator of Victoria (Australia) writes that cuts to the non-knife hand or arm are the most common injury, advises always putting the knife in a scabbard when not in use, and says not to store knives on wall fittings or locker shelves. The Western Australian regulator, reporting on abattoir inspections, called the knife the most common tool in the industry and the cause of the most lost-time injuries, and listed knives left unsecured around the workplace among common issues.
The second concerns the product. A knife touches raw meat, and put down on a table or in a crate it carries whatever is on it to the next surface. For why this matters microbiologically, see the article on Listeria and sanitation.
What do the regulations say about knives and sterilizers?
Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Annex II, Chapter V, point 1 requires articles, fittings and equipment that come into contact with food to be effectively cleaned and, where necessary, disinfected, often enough to avoid any risk of contamination.
Regulation (EC) No 853/2004, Annex III, Section I (meat of domestic ungulates) goes further. Slaughterhouses (Chapter II, point 3) and cutting plants (Chapter III, point 5) must have facilities for disinfecting tools with hot water at not less than 82 °C, or an alternative system with an equivalent effect. The same wording appears for poultry and for minced meat and meat preparation establishments. The regulation is silent on where a knife lies between operations. It is an EU rule; in our view it is more a benchmark for a Ukrainian plant.
In Ukraine the hygiene requirements rest on Order No. 590 of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy. The word "knife" does not appear in it. Clause 2.4.2 covers the condition of equipment and protection of food from contamination, and clauses 2.9.1 and 2.9.2 cover documented cleaning procedures and cleaning and disinfection methods chosen by surface. Where knives lie between operations, the plant writes into its own procedures. We did not find a Ukrainian occupational safety rule requiring knife scabbards, so look for that in internal instructions. More on audits: HACCP and video control.
Can a camera check that knives are sterilized?
No. At the plant where we ran the system the sterilizers were closed units, and the cameras did not see them. Water temperature, immersion time or the fact of disinfection are for the log, the thermometer and your responsible person.
After the requirement was clarified, the rule was narrowed to what a camera can see: a knife lies at a workstation and nobody is near it for longer than a set time. It covers an abandoned knife; a knife in use does not count. The rule ran on six deboning cameras.
How does a camera see an unattended knife?
The system finds a knife in the frame and checks that it stays still. If nobody is near it for longer than the set time, a card appears with a frame, the camera and the time. The responsible person presses "violation" or "reject". We do not name the person; the card shows the place and the knife.
The condition "no person nearby" matters. In one review an object lay at a workstation where people worked almost all the time, so the countdown kept being interrupted. By the definition of the rule, a knife in use is not abandoned.
Where did the camera get it wrong for us?
First, technological holes in table tops were taken for knives. Two detections on one camera fell on a single still point of an empty table, and a table zone did not help because the hole lay inside the correct zone. We taught the rule to treat a point where an object is almost always present as background. The side effect: a knife lying in one place for a long time may also become background, so the card has to appear before the place becomes permanent.
Second, a miss. In one case an object lay on a table for more than half an hour and there was no card. The rule settings were not the cause: on 12 frames the system hardly recognised the object, while a knife with a blue handle on the same table was recognised. Magnified, the object looked like scissors, so whether it was a knife stayed an open question. We also had to check that the system does not mix up blue chain mail gloves with knives.
The counts are small and come from different samples. Before the fixes the rule produced 70 cards and people confirmed 17. In the week after the fixes there were 8 cards and 5 were confirmed. This counts cards; it does not measure accuracy.
Is the rule ready for your plant?
No. The knife rule is not among those we have proven on meat processing. It was only tuned, and there was no independent accuracy check, so we quote no percentages. It worked as a prompt: a card with a frame that your person decides on.
- The camera does not see a closed sterilizer and does not check temperature.
- It does not see a knife in a scabbard, under product or outside the frame.
- The difference between a knife and scissors depends on the frame.
- You set how long a knife may lie before it counts as left; another deboning line may need a different value.
The general launch story: our experience in a meat plant.
Where to start?
- Write down in your procedures where knives lie between operations, what they are stored in and who is responsible for the sterilizer.
- Show us the cameras over the deboning tables. A few hours of footage is enough.
- We draw the zones, run the footage through the system and show you the cards, including the false ones such as holes in tables.
- The rule first runs in shadow mode, and you decide.
Contact details are on the Contacts page.
Where to apply this
- Food safety and hygiene
- Meat processing
- Food manufacturing
- Dish pass time in a restaurant: what to count and how a camera does it
- Restaurant kitchen control with a camera: sanitation, HACCP and what the camera checks
- Video analytics for a restaurant: what it does in the kitchen, at the pass and in the dining room
Sources
- Regulation (EC) No 853/2004, Annex III, Section I: Chapter II point 3 (slaughterhouses) and Chapter III point 5 (cutting plants)
- Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 on the hygiene of foodstuffs, Annex II, Chapter V, point 1
- Order of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy of Ukraine of October 1, 2012, No. 590 («Про затвердження Вимог щодо розробки, впровадження та застосування постійно діючих процедур, заснованих на принципах НАССР»), clauses 2.4.2, 2.9.1, 2.9.2
- WorkSafe Victoria: Safe use of knives in the meat and food industry
- WorkSafe Western Australia: Abattoir safety standards sharpened thanks to inspection program (10 February 2026)