Phone in a food production area: why it is banned and how a camera spots it in a hand
Author: DuoVision team
For: heads of HACCP, process engineers, and shift supervisors at food and meat processing plants
Summary
- A phone is banned near exposed product for three reasons: it can end up in the product, it carries microbes from hand to hand and back, and it distracts people near knives and machines.
- Order No. 590 and Regulation (EC) 852/2004 do not mention phones directly. The enterprise writes the ban into its own conduct rules, and the camera checks those rules.
- The camera looks for a phone in a person's hand inside a zone and sends an event card with a frame. Your responsible person makes the decision.
- At the meat processing plant where we ran the system, the rule worked on the deboning cameras, but it was only tuned: there was no independent accuracy check for it, so we do not quote percentages.
- We tune it to your site, starting in shadow mode.
For: heads of HACCP, process engineers, and shift supervisors at food and meat processing plants
Why is a phone banned in a food production area?
Three reasons are usually given.
- Foreign object. A phone, its case, back cover, screen glass or protective film can end up in the product if the device is dropped or put down on a table next to raw material. We wrote about why foreign objects are dangerous and how they are found in the article on foreign objects in food.
- Microbes. A phone is touched with dirty hands, carried in a pocket and taken outside. This is our reasoning, the regulations do not say it: if it is picked up again in the production area, clean hands stop being clean. Hospital data is below.
- Attention. A person with a phone in a hand looks at the screen, and the knife, the belt or the packing machine drop out of view. We cite no separate study of this in food plants; it is a reasoning from workplace safety practice.
What is known about bacteria on mobile phones?
We found a review in which the authors analysed 30 articles on mobile devices in hospitals (R. Szabó, J. Morvai, Antimicrobial Resistance and Infection Control, 2015). According to them, bacterial contamination of devices ranged from 40% to 100%, most often coagulase-negative staphylococci and Staphylococcus aureus. Only 8% of healthcare workers cleaned their devices regularly.
A caveat: this is hospital data that does not cover food plants, and we read only the abstract of the review. For a production area the conclusion is this: a phone that nobody disinfects easily becomes one more place from which hands pick up microbes. How much it contributes to contamination of product at a particular plant, we do not know, and we do not invent figures for a food plant.
What do the regulations say about mobile phones in production?
Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Annex II, Chapter VIII, point 1, requires people working in a food-handling area to maintain a high degree of personal cleanliness and to wear suitable, clean clothing. Phones are not in that point.
In Ukraine the basis is Order No. 590 of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy. Clause 2.10.5 concerns staff conduct rules in production, including entering and leaving areas and carrying personal items and jewellery. We did not find the word "phone" in the part of the page we read. So the exact ban, where a phone is allowed, where it is left, and whether it may be used in the staff room, is written by the enterprise into its own conduct rules. An auditor usually checks that the rule is written down and followed. For more on audits, see the article on HACCP and video control.
How does a camera spot a phone in a hand?
The system finds a person in the zone, looks at their hands and searches for a phone. If one is there for several frames in a row, an event card appears with a frame, the camera and the time. The responsible person presses "violation" or "reject". The general logic is the same as in the guide to PPE control with cameras.
A phone in a production camera frame is very small, and that is the main difficulty. We checked this on eight frames where the rule had earlier recorded a phone in a hand. When the system searched the whole frame, it found the phone on only one of the eight. When it looked at people up close, it found six of the eight. The sample is small, so this shows only why the way of looking matters; it does not show how accurate the rule is.
On 16 production frames with no phone there were no false finds. That is also only 16 frames.
What was our experience?
At the meat processing plant where we ran the system, the phone rule worked on the deboning cameras. By the first human verdicts there were five cards: three confirmed and two rejected. Nobody draws conclusions from five cards, so we publish no percentage.
The developer who looked at the cards every day judged that the rule worked well. That is an impression; there was no measurement. A wider summary of the launch is in the article on our experience launching in a meat plant.
We have not run an independent accuracy check for this rule. We proved the hair net, mask, glove and crate-on-the-floor rules in work at the meat processing plant; the phone rule was only tuned.
What will the camera not see?
- A phone in a pocket, under an apron or in a sleeve. The camera sees only what is visible.
- A phone in a clenched hand, or hidden by the body or a table.
- Places outside the frame: behind a column, in a blind corner, in a changing room with no camera.
- The difference between a phone and a similar object: a radio, a logging tablet, a scanner, a remote. They are easy to confuse, so we discuss allowed devices with you separately.
We do not recognise faces. A card says where and when; who it is, the system does not determine.
Where to start?
- Write down in your rules where phones are banned, where they are left, and which devices are allowed.
- Show us the cameras that look at these areas. A few hours of footage is enough.
- We run the footage and show you the cards, including the false ones.
- The rule first runs in shadow mode: you see how many cards your people confirmed. We move to live mode when it suits you.
Food and bottles at a workstation are covered in eating at the workstation in food production.
We tune it to the site. A phone in a production camera is small, and the result depends on height, angle and lighting. Contact details are on the Contacts page.
Where to apply this
- Food safety and hygiene
- Meat processing
- Food manufacturing
- Dish pass time in a restaurant: what to count and how a camera does it
- Restaurant kitchen control with a camera: sanitation, HACCP and what the camera checks
- Video analytics for a restaurant: what it does in the kitchen, at the pass and in the dining room
Sources
- Order of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy and Food of October 1, 2012, No. 590 «Про затвердження Вимог щодо розробки, впровадження та застосування постійно діючих процедур, заснованих на принципах НАССР» (“On Approval of the Requirements for the Development, Implementation, and Application of Permanent Procedures Based on HACCP Principles”), clause 2.10.5
- Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 on the hygiene of foodstuffs, Annex II, Chapter VIII
- Szabó R., Morvai J. The role of the mobile communication devices in the spread of healthcare-associated infections: a systematic review. Antimicrob Resist Infect Control 2015;4(Suppl 1):P39