- Home
- Resources
- Food at the workstation in a production area: what the regulations say and how a camera spots it
Food at the workstation in a production area: what the regulations say and how a camera spots it
Author: DuoVision team
For: heads of HACCP, process engineers, and shift supervisors at food and meat processing plants
Summary
- Ukrainian Order No. 590 does not ban eating at a food production workstation outright. It requires the operator to set staff conduct rules that cover eating and smoking (items 2.10.1 and 2.10.5). Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 has no direct ban either, but requires a high degree of personal cleanliness, so the plant writes the limits into its own rules.
- By sanitation logic (our reasoning, the regulations do not say it) food, drinks and chewing in an area with exposed product bring crumbs, residue and household waste into the workshop and can attract pests. So plants move eating to a separate place.
- A camera looks for food and bottles at workstations in a defined zone and sends an event card with a frame. The responsible person decides.
- At the meat processing plant where we ran the system, the food rule ran only in shadow mode and was only tuned. There was no independent accuracy check for it, so we do not quote percentages.
- The first thing we did was check for false alarms: in a day of frames, none of 18 detected objects turned out to be real food.
For: heads of HACCP, process engineers, and shift supervisors at food and meat processing plants
Why can't people eat, drink or chew in a production area?
Where product is exposed, any household item becomes a potential source of contamination. Food leaves crumbs and residue, an open bottle can spill, and after eating a person touches the face, gloves and the table. This is our reasoning from sanitation logic, the regulations do not say it, and it is the same for meat processing, bakery and dairy.
There is a second side. Food residue at a workstation probably attracts rodents and insects; how that connects to Listeria and plant sanitation is in our article on Listeria and sanitation. Household packaging or a bottle cap can also become a foreign object. Recall and complaint data are in the article on foreign objects in food, and we do not repeat them here.
What do the regulations say about eating at work in food production?
In Ukraine the basis is Order No. 590 of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy on procedures based on HACCP principles. Clause 2.10.1 obliges the operator to introduce conduct rules for staff, contractors and visitors who may come into contact with exposed food. Clause 2.10.5 lists what these rules must cover: entering and leaving rooms, personal items and jewellery, actions after cuts, eating, hand washing, smoking, toilet visits, and storage and use of clothing and footwear.
So the order does not say "eating is forbidden". It requires rules on eating and smoking, and what those rules say is for the enterprise to decide. We found no words on drinking or chewing in that clause, so it is worth writing them into your own rules too.
Regulation (EC) No 852/2004, Annex II, Chapter VIII, point 1, requires everyone working in a food-handling area to maintain a high degree of personal cleanliness and wear clean clothing. There is no direct ban on eating there. The regulation mentions dining areas separately, as an exception to the requirements for rooms where food is prepared. For more on regulations and audits, see the article on HACCP and video control.
How does a camera spot food and bottles at a workstation?
For each camera we draw a zone: a table, a line, a deboning station. The system watches for an object that looks like food or a bottle appearing in the zone, and whether a person is holding it. If so, an event card appears with a frame, the camera and the time. The responsible person decides: violation or reject. We do not recognise faces.
We build this rule as a shadow rule from the start. It collects cards, people review them, and only when false cards become few do we decide whether to switch it to live mode. We approach every new rule this way; the general order of rollout is in the article on our experience launching in a meat plant.
What happened in our experience?
At the meat plant where we ran the system, the food rule was first "blind". It was marked as live, but over seven days it produced one card, and that one came from cameras that had already been switched off. The rule was silent because it saw no frames, and behind that silence violations could well have been happening.
We rewrote the rule and connected eight cameras instead of two switched-off ones. Before that we looked at what a general object search finds on these cameras over a single day. It found 18 "objects", and none of them turned out to be real. Among them was a bottle that the system confidently saw on the empty door of a locker. So the very object the rule relies on had already produced a confident invention.
That is why we kept the rule in shadow mode. We have not yet checked it by hand, putting a bottle in the frame and seeing whether the system notices it. So everything here is an observation from one day on these cameras; they do not show accuracy.
Can this check be trusted already?
Not without a trial on your own cameras. We checked the hair net, mask, glove and crate-on-the-floor rules at the meat plant, while the food rule was only tuned. We tune it to each site, and we will give numbers on its accuracy only after a check on a separate sample of frames. The rules we checked at the plant are described in the articles on hair net control, glove control and boxes on the floor.
What does the camera not see?
- Chewing and drinking with nothing in the hand: a sweet in the mouth, or a sip from a bottle hidden under a coat.
- Food behind a column or in a blind corner, outside the frame.
- Objects that look like food or a bottle but are not. In our measurement one such invention appeared on a locker door.
- The difference between a person eating and a person merely holding something. A card says an object was in the zone, and a person decides.
So we do not point the rule at places where food is allowed under your rules, such as near the break room, and we draw the zone only where product is exposed.
Where to start?
- Write down in your rules where people may eat and drink, where they may not, and how this applies to chewing and water.
- Show us the cameras that look at workstations with exposed product. A few hours of footage is enough.
- We draw the zones, run the footage through the system, and show you the cards, including the false ones.
- The rule first runs in shadow mode, and we move to live mode when it suits you.
For phones in the product area, see the article on phones in a food plant. Contact details are on the Contacts page.
Frequently asked questions
Is eating at the workstation banned in food production?
Order No. 590 does not say "eating is forbidden". It requires the operator to introduce conduct rules for staff, contractors and visitors who may come into contact with exposed food, and those rules must cover eating and smoking (items 2.10.1 and 2.10.5). Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 has no direct ban on eating either. What the rules say is for the enterprise to decide.
Does Order 590 ban drinking and chewing gum?
We found no words on drinking or chewing in item 2.10.5, so it is worth writing them into your own rules.
Can a camera detect eating at a workstation?
A camera looks for an object that looks like food or a bottle in a zone drawn for the workstation and creates a card with a frame, the camera and the time. The responsible person decides whether it is a violation. It does not see chewing or drinking with nothing in the hand, or food behind a column or in a blind corner.
Has the food rule been checked yet?
No. At the meat processing plant where we ran the system, it ran only in shadow mode and was tuned, with no independent accuracy check, so we do not quote percentages. We checked the hair net, mask, glove and crate-on-the-floor rules at the meat processing plant.
Where to apply this
- Food safety and hygiene
- Meat processing
- Food manufacturing
- Dish pass time in a restaurant: what to count and how a camera does it
- Restaurant kitchen control with a camera: sanitation, HACCP and what the camera checks
- Video analytics for a restaurant: what it does in the kitchen, at the pass and in the dining room
Sources
- Order of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy and Food of October 1, 2012, No. 590 «Про затвердження Вимог щодо розробки, впровадження та застосування постійно діючих процедур, заснованих на принципах НАССР» (“On Approval of the Requirements for the Development, Implementation, and Application of Permanent Procedures Based on HACCP Principles”), clauses 2.10.1 and 2.10.5
- Regulation (EC) No 852/2004 on the hygiene of foodstuffs, Annex II, Chapter VIII