Internal HACCP audit checklist: what to check and where video evidence saves effort
Author: DuoVision team
For: technologists, heads of quality and HACCP, internal auditors at food plants
Summary
- An internal HACCP audit is a verification of the system: a check that the HACCP plan works and is followed, carried out at least once a year or after changes to processes or products. Order No. 590 of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy calls it verification (item 3.25) and does not use the term "internal audit".
- Verification is done by a person who is not responsible for monitoring and corrective actions. If that cannot be done in house, external experts are brought in.
- The checklist below is built from the order: documentation, prerequisite programmes, critical control points, corrective actions, records. For each block it says what to check and whether video evidence can help.
- Video covers only the items about people's behavior and the state of zones. It does not replace instruments, laboratory swabs, medical examinations or documents.
For: technologists, heads of quality and HACCP, internal auditors at food plants
What the order says about checking the system
Item 3.25 of Order No. 590 describes the sixth HACCP principle, verification. Its purpose is to make sure the HACCP plan is well grounded, controls the hazards and is actually followed. The order names the inputs for verification directly: a review of complaints, results of laboratory monitoring, results of CCP monitoring, equipment calibration, results of audits and inspections, a check of record keeping, an analysis of deviations and a check of the work of responsible staff.
On frequency: verification is done at least once a year, or when technological processes or products change in a way that affects safety. For a recently introduced system the order recommends doing it more often. It is carried out by a person who is not responsible for monitoring or corrective actions, and if that cannot be done in house, external experts are engaged.
Separately there is validation of the HACCP plan (item 3.25.2.1): it is done before implementation and then at a set frequency and on changes. The order lists the cases: a new product or line, new equipment, a change of technology, a change of suppliers, an extended shelf life. Validation answers "is the plan itself right", verification answers "is it followed and does it work". Below is a checklist for verification, that is, an internal audit in the usual sense.
How to use the checklist
Close each item with "yes", "partly" or "no" and add a link to a document or a frame. The "Video evidence" column shows whether an item can be confirmed with a frame:
- "Yes, checked by us" means we tested the rule on real events at the meat processing plant where we ran the system;
- "Can be set up" means it is possible in principle, but for your site the rule has to be configured and first checked in shadow mode;
- "No" means a camera will not help here.
Item numbers in the "Basis" column are items of Order No. 590 unless stated otherwise.
Block 1. Documentation and the HACCP team
| What to check | Basis | Video evidence |
|---|---|---|
| The HACCP team is set up, its composition and duties are written down | 3.4, 3.26.2 | No |
| There is a product description, a flow diagram, a hazard analysis and a method for determining CCPs | 3.26.2 | No |
| Critical limits are written down and justified | 3.22, 3.26.2 | No |
| The plan was reviewed after changes in product, process or ingredients | Law, art. 21, part 5; order 3.25.2.1 | No |
| There are minutes of HACCP team meetings | 3.26.3 | No |
Block 2. Prerequisite programmes
| What to check | Basis | Video evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning, washing and disinfection procedures are documented and carried out at the set frequency; the check is done by someone who does not do the cleaning | 2.9.1, 2.9.4, 2.9.5, 2.9.6 | Can be set up: state of zones, crates and boxes. It does not confirm the result of washing |
| Rules of conduct for staff, contractors and visitors exist and are known | 2.10.1, 2.10.5, 2.10.6 | Yes, checked by us: cap or hairnet, mask, beard cover, gloves. The rest can be set up |
| Work clothing is clean, sufficient in number, and laundering procedures are verified | 2.10.3 | Can be set up: whether people in the zone are wearing work clothing |
| Check of employees before work, exclusion of sick staff, medical books (see staff health log) | 2.10.2, 2.10.4; Law, art. 48 | No |
| Product is protected from contamination (under your rules boxes do not stand on the floor) | 2.6, the general requirement to protect from contamination | Yes, checked by us: a box directly on the floor |
| Pest control measures are in place, doors and openings sealed, control devices marked and inspected | 2.12.2, 2.12.4 | Can be set up: open doors and gates. A camera does not check the state of traps |
| Waste is removed on schedule, collection points are defined | 2.11 | Can be set up: waste piling up in a zone |
| Toxic substances are stored and used under the programme rules | 2.13 | No |
| Raw material specifications, suppliers assessed | 2.14 | No |
| Storage and transport conditions, temperature and humidity | 2.15 | No (instruments take the readings) |
| Control of technological processes | 2.16 | Depends on the process, can be set up |
| Labeling and batch identification | 2.17 | No |
Items 2.5, 2.7 and 2.8 of the order (premises layout, utilities, water) are checked on a walkthrough and against documents and are not broken down in this checklist.
Block 3. Critical control points
| What to check | Basis | Video evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Each CCP has a parameter, a method, a frequency and a person responsible for monitoring | 3.23.4 | No |
| Monitoring protocols are filled in right after the measurement and signed by the performer | 3.23.1, 3.23.5 | No |
| An authorized person checks monitoring data | 3.23.3, 3.23.5 | No |
| Instruments are calibrated, accuracy is checked | 3.23.4.2 | No |
| Trends toward loss of control were spotted before an actual deviation | 3.23.2 | No |
Block 4. Deviations and corrective actions
| What to check | Basis | Video evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Corrective actions and a responsible person are defined in advance for each CCP | 3.24.1, 3.24.4, 3.24.5 | No |
| The steps of a corrective action are documented (for example date, time, action, performer, next check) | 3.24.6 | Partly: confirmed cards show that a violation was reviewed |
| The action restores control, finds and removes the cause, identifies potentially unsafe product | 3.24.3 | No |
| Frequent deviations in one area were analyzed at the system level | 3.24.7 | Yes, if the rule is set up: number of violations by area and shift from the card log |
Block 5. Records
| What to check | Basis | Video evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Records are properly drawn up and understandable to staff | 3.26.4 | No |
| Only authorized persons make corrections | 3.26.7 | No (for a card log, check access roles) |
| Electronic records are complete, protected from unauthorized changes and available on request | 3.26.5 | Applies to an electronic log of cards too |
| Documents and records are kept for at least three months after the minimum durability date or use-by date | Law, art. 21, part 6, item 3 | If cards are your record, the same period applies (our interpretation) |
| Traceability of batches at all stages | Law, art. 22 | No |
Block 6. The verification itself
| What to check | Basis | Video evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Verification was carried out within a year or after changes in processes and products | 3.25.2.2 | No |
| It was done by a person not responsible for monitoring and corrective actions, or by an external expert | 3.25.2.2 | No |
| Inputs used: complaints, laboratory data, CCP monitoring data, calibration, audits, a check of records, deviation analysis, a check of staff work | 3.25.2.2 | Partly: a sample of frames for "a check of the work of staff" |
Where video evidence makes the audit easier
An internal auditor cannot stand in the workshop all year, so a check of staff behavior is usually reduced to one or two walkthroughs. A walkthrough shows one shift. If a rule runs on the cameras, the log holds all events for the period, and the auditor can:
- take a random sample of confirmed cards and check that each has a correction and a corrective action;
- look at how the number of violations changed by shift and area, and tie that to item 3.24.7 on systemic deviations;
- check whether the same violations repeated after a corrective action;
- show an external auditor that deviations are both found and reviewed.
For that the card must hold a frame, a time, a camera, a rule and the decision of the responsible person. A number without a sample proves nothing, so in the report write how many events there were and over what period. An example wording: X of N cards confirmed in a given month.
For what external auditors ask, read HACCP and video monitoring, and for the logs themselves see HACCP log sample. If you are new to the system, start with what HACCP is.
What video does not replace
- Instrument readings, temperature, concentration of agents. An instrument does that and a person records it.
- Laboratory swabs and microbiological tests.
- Medical examinations, admission to work, staff training.
- Assessment of the HACCP plan and critical limits, that is, validation.
- The decision. The system is run by a responsible person, not a camera.
Where to start
- Appoint who will carry out verification and who is not responsible for monitoring and corrective actions.
- Go through the checklist above, close each item with an answer and a link to a document.
- Mark the items about people's behavior and the state of zones and decide which of them you want to confirm with a frame.
- For those rules run shadow mode on your cameras and count how many cards your people confirmed over a period.
- Plan the next verification within a year and after any significant change.
We tune the system to each site and start in shadow mode.
Frequently asked questions
How often should an internal HACCP audit be done?
Verification is done at least once a year, or when technological processes or products change in a way that affects safety (item 3.25 of Order No. 590). For a recently introduced system the order recommends doing it more often.
Who can carry out an internal HACCP audit?
A person who is not responsible for monitoring and corrective actions. If that cannot be done in house, external experts are engaged.
What is the difference between validation and verification in HACCP?
Validation answers whether the plan itself is right and is done before implementation and on changes such as a new product, new equipment or a change of suppliers (item 3.25.2.1). Verification answers whether the plan is followed and works, and it is what the checklist above covers.
Can video replace parts of an internal audit?
Only the items about people's behavior and the state of zones, and only where a rule has been set up and checked on your cameras. Video does not replace instrument readings, laboratory swabs, medical examinations, documents or the audit decision.
Where to apply this
- Food safety and hygiene
- Meat processing
- Food manufacturing
- Occupational safety
- Dish pass time in a restaurant: what to count and how a camera does it
- Restaurant kitchen control with a camera: sanitation, HACCP and what the camera checks
- Video analytics for a restaurant: what it does in the kitchen, at the pass and in the dining room
Sources
- Order of the Ministry of Agrarian Policy of 01.10.2012 No. 590 "On approval of requirements for developing, implementing and applying permanent procedures based on the principles of the food safety management system (HACCP)" (section II, items 3.4, 3.22-3.26)
- Law of Ukraine "On basic principles and requirements for the safety and quality of food products" of 23.12.1997 No. 771/97-VR (articles 21, 22, 48; edition of 22.07.2026)